Stephen Neal Quoting Thaddeus Stevens

Description

The Drafter of the 14th Amendment Quotes Abolitionist Congressman Thaddeus Stevens
STEPHEN NEAL.
Autograph Note Signed. 1 p., 8¼ x 4¼ in.
Inventory #23151
Complete Transcript
In the debate in the C.
[Congressional]
Globe, you will see that the great Statesman and true patriot, Hon. Thadeus
[sic]
Stevens said “The propositions fall short of my wishes, but they fulfill my hopes.” &c. I am very busy in my judicial duties, or would write you more fully.
S.N.
Historical Background
Stephen Neal
(1817-1905) was an Indiana lawyer. He served in the state legislature and was later a judge. In 1866, he drafted what would become the 14
th
Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Legend has it that he presented it his friend, Indiana Congressman Godlove S. Orth, and that Congress passed the draft as Neal had written it. This is unlikely; Ohio Congressman John Bingham is usually given credit as the amendment’s principal author, to say nothing of Congressional machinations that make passage of anything without revision nearly impossible.
Neal is actually summarizing Stevens’s arguments in the House of Representatives:
“When I say that we should rejoice at such completion [of the amendment], I do not thereby intend so much to express joy at the superior excellence of the scheme, as that there is to be a scheme—a scheme containing much positive good, as well, I am bound to admit, as the omission of many better things.”
“Do you inquire why, holding these views and possessing some will of my own, I accept so imperfect a proposition? I answer, because I live among men and not among angels; among men as intelligent, as determined, and as independent as myself, who, not agreeing with me, do not choose to yield their opinions to mine. Mutual concession, therefore, is our only resort, or mutual hostilities. We might well have been justified in making renewed and more strenuous efforts for a better plan could we have had the coöperation of the Executive.”
“A few words will suffice to explain the changes made by the Senate in the proposition which we sent to them.”
“You perceive that while I see much good in the proposition I do not pretend to be satisfied with it. And yet I am anxious for its speedy adoption, for I dread delay. The danger is that before any Constitutional guards shall have been adopted Congress will be flooded by rebels and rebel sympathizers....Hence, I say, let us no longer delay; take what we can get now, and hope for better things in further legislation; in enabling acts or other provisions.”
From the Congressional Globe, June 13, 1866, p. 3148.
SETH KALLER, INC.
Historic Documents and Legacy Collections
For over 20 years, Seth Kaller has been one of the country’s largest buyers of important historic documents and artifacts. More than 10,000 rare  manuscripts, documents, maps, and books handled by Kaller are now in  institutional and private collections including working drafts of the  United States Constitution, Lincoln-signed copies of the 13th Amendment  and Emancipation Proclamation, and rare prints and broadsides of the  Declaration of Independence.
Kaller is a member of the Antiquarian Booksellers’ Association of America  (ABAA), the Professional Autograph Dealers Association (PADA), the  American Antiquarian Society, the Manuscript Society, the New-York  Historical Society’s Chairman’s Council, and the Papers of Abraham  Lincoln Advisory Board.
Authenticity Guaranteed
Everything we sell comes with our absolute guarantee that it is original and  authentic. If this is ever proven not to be authentic it may be returned for a full refund.
History You Can Own
Whether you’re interested in the Founding Fathers, Documents of Freedom,  Battles and Leaders, the Civil War, African-Americana, World History,  Science, or a particular hero or villain, we can help you explore  opportunities to take ownership of history.
Build Your Own Collection
We can coordinate every aspect of the process for you, from searching for  individual items to building entire world-class collections for your  home, business, foundation, or favorite museum. We can handle the  pre-acquisition research, physical inspection and purchasing, auction  representation, authentication, inventory, accounting reports, framing,  and display.
Help Your Favorite Institution
Build a legacy by preserving history for generations to come. Through  donations and loans to your favorite museum, library, or university, you ensure the survival of these important documents and act as a steward  for personalities and ideas that shaped the world. We handle all the  arrangements including insurance, transit, and proper acknowledgement  for you. Donating can also bring substantial tax benefits. We have  considerable experience working with tax attorneys and accountants to  help maximize your benefit or minimize your cost as you promote your  passion for history.